10 Best Pelago Alternatives & Competitors (2026)

HealthCare.com delivers an online platform for comparing and enrolling in ACA plans with some agent partnership features. It provides educational content and plan finders similar to HealthSherpa but without the same emphasis on 7-minute applications or carrier-integrated ecosystems for agencies. Brokers seeking alternatives may choose it for its consumer branding strength.

Stride Health focuses on ACA and ICHRA enrollment with personalized plan recommendations and employer tools. It targets both individuals and small businesses, offering a different use case than HealthSherpa's agent-centric quoting speed. Agencies evaluating alternatives might prefer Stride for ICHRA support but could miss HealthSherpa's free model and broker training resources.

Policygenius is an insurance brokerage platform covering health, life, and other lines with digital quoting and licensed agent support. While it handles ACA plans, its broader scope differs from HealthSherpa's specialized ACA and Medicare focus. Agents may consider it for multi-line needs but HealthSherpa remains stronger for pure enrollment speed and agency volume tracking.

Insurify provides instant insurance quotes primarily for auto and home but has expanded into health plan comparisons. Its algorithmic approach contrasts with HealthSherpa's agent workflow tools and carrier partnerships. It serves as an alternative mainly for brokers wanting quick consumer-facing quotes rather than full ACA enrollment management.

EverQuote runs a digital insurance marketplace that generates leads for agents across multiple lines including health. It differs from HealthSherpa by focusing on lead volume instead of in-platform enrollment speed or Medicare-specific features. Agencies might explore it to supplement HealthSherpa when seeking additional consumer traffic sources.

Array Health offers enrollment and benefits administration software aimed at employers and exchanges. Its platform supports ACA compliance and ICHRA setups with more enterprise features than HealthSherpa's agent tools. It serves as an alternative for carriers or larger agencies needing integrated operations beyond basic quoting.

Benefitfocus provides benefits administration and enrollment platforms primarily for employers and carriers. It includes ACA reporting and employee decision support, offering deeper HR integration than HealthSherpa's broker-focused solution. Agencies handling large group business may evaluate it as a complement or replacement for complex use cases.

Vertafore delivers agency management systems with insurance quoting, CRM, and compliance tools across lines of business. Its robust back-office features differ from HealthSherpa's lightweight, free ACA enrollment emphasis. Established agencies might consider Vertafore when they need full agency management alongside quoting capabilities.