LoyaltyLion alternatives
12 products compared · Updated November 2, 2026
The short answer
The three strongest LoyaltyLion alternatives are Smile.io for Shopify and BigCommerce brands that want transparent pricing and a free plan, Growave for Shopify merchants that want loyalty, reviews, and wishlists in one app, and Yotpo for ecommerce brands that want to combine loyalty with reviews and AI visibility. Each suits a different priority: Smile.io for budget clarity, Growave for feature consolidation, and Yotpo for unified customer content and AI search control.
Your shortlist, at a glance
Read the comparisons ↓- SSmile.ioFree, then $15/moShopify and BigCommerce brands that want a loyalty program with transparent pricing and a free plan to start.
YotpoCustom quoteEcommerce brands that want a single platform for loyalty, reviews, and AI search visibility.
KlaviyoFree plan availableEcommerce brands that want a full marketing platform with email, SMS, and customer data, not just loyalty points.- GGrowaveFrom $199/moShopify brands that want loyalty, reviews, and wishlists in one platform with a simpler bill and one vendor.
- RRise.aiNot publishedShopify stores that want to automate gift cards, store credit refunds, and cashback to boost retention.
- LLoyaltyLoopFrom $50/mo + $50 setuFranchises and multi-location businesses that want a managed NPS and review collection process without adding internal workload
Awtomic$249/mo + 1%/orderWineries and ecommerce brands on Shopify that need wine clubs, subscriptions, and memberships with built-in billing and member management.
Appstle SubscriptionsNot publishedShopify merchants who need deep subscription customization and want loyalty, memberships, and bundles in one app.
Bold UpsellNot publishedShopify merchants who want to boost AOV with AI-driven upsells and integrate with subscriptions, memberships, and custom pricing tools.Loop SubscriptionsNot publishedShopify brands that sell subscriptions and want to reduce churn with built-in retention tools.
RechargeNot publishedShopify brands that sell subscriptions and want loyalty features bundled with their subscription management.
RecurpayFree / $19 / $99 per mShopify brands that want a fast-to-launch subscription engine with dunning and a self-serve customer portal
About LoyaltyLion and its alternatives
LoyaltyLion is an ecommerce loyalty platform that offers AI-driven rewards, referrals, and retention tools. It is known for its headless API, 130+ language support, and integrations with 100+ partners, with pricing starting at $199 per month for the Classic plan.
When comparing alternatives, weigh pricing structure, platform compatibility, integration depth, support quality, and contract terms. Some tools charge per order, others per location, and many require contacting sales for quotes. Consider whether you need a dedicated loyalty engine or a broader retention suite that includes subscriptions, reviews, or gift cards.
Explore the alternatives
- SFree, then $15/mo
1.Smile.io
Best for: Shopify and BigCommerce brands that want a loyalty program with transparent pricing and a free plan to start.

- Pricing
- Free, then $15/mo
- Category
- Other
Smile.io is a loyalty platform built specifically for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands, offering points, VIP tiers, referrals, and cashback. You'd choose it over LoyaltyLion if you're on Shopify and want a platform with a free tier, clear published pricing, and a dedicated migration team that can move your members and points over.
Where it is strong
- Free plan available for new stores with up to 200 monthly orders.
- Pricing is published and scales with monthly order volume.
- Dedicated migration team can carry over members, point balances, and VIP tiers from LoyaltyLion.
Where it falls short
- Primarily built for Shopify and BigCommerce, so not ideal for other platforms.
- Advanced features like API access and custom reports are only on the $999/mo Plus plan or higher.
- Pricing:
- Free for up to 200 monthly orders, then $15/mo for 500 orders, $79/mo for 1,000 orders, $199/mo for 2,500 orders, $999/mo for 7,500 orders, and custom for enterprise.
- Switching from LoyaltyLion:
- Smile.io offers a white-glove migration service that moves your members, point balances, and VIP tiers over, with one brand completing the switch in about a week.
Custom quote2.Yotpo
Best for: Ecommerce brands that want a single platform for loyalty, reviews, and AI search visibility.

- Pricing
- Custom quote
- Category
- E-commerce
Yotpo combines loyalty, reviews, and AI visibility in one platform. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if you want to manage customer reviews and loyalty together, or if you care about controlling how AI engines recommend your products.
Where it is strong
- Combines loyalty, reviews, and AI visibility in one platform
- 180+ integrations to unify your martech stack
- AI-powered review summaries and smart sorting
Where it falls short
- Pricing is not transparent. Requires contacting sales
- Loyalty features may be less customizable than LoyaltyLion's headless API
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site. Plans are available for reviews, loyalty, and AI visibility, but you need to contact sales for quotes.
Free plan available3.Klaviyo
Best for: Ecommerce brands that want a full marketing platform with email, SMS, and customer data, not just loyalty points.

- Pricing
- Free plan available
- Category
- Marketing & Sales
Klaviyo is a B2C CRM and marketing platform that unifies email, SMS, and other channels with customer data. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your priority is broad marketing automation and lifecycle campaigns rather than a dedicated loyalty program.
Where it is strong
- Unifies email, SMS, push, WhatsApp, and web events into one customer profile.
- AI agents like Composer and Customer Agent automate campaigns and support.
- 400+ pre-built integrations, including Shopify and other ecommerce platforms.
Where it falls short
- Loyalty features are not native. You would need to build or integrate a loyalty program separately.
- Pricing scales with contacts, so costs can grow quickly for large lists.
- Pricing:
- Klaviyo offers a free plan and paid plans that scale based on contacts and channel usage. Enterprise pricing is available.
- GFrom $199/mo
4.Growave
Best for: Shopify brands that want loyalty, reviews, and wishlists in one platform with a simpler bill and one vendor.

- Pricing
- From $199/mo
- Category
- Other
Growave is a Shopify-native loyalty and retention platform that bundles loyalty points, referrals, reviews, wishlists, and UGC into one app. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if you want to replace a multi-app stack with a single tool that shares one customer profile across all five features.
Where it is strong
- Combines loyalty, referrals, reviews, wishlists, and UGC in one app
- Klaviyo integration built in, with tier changes firing Shopify tags
- Contract buyout: free until your current loyalty contract ends
Where it falls short
- Shopify-only, so not for non-Shopify ecommerce platforms
- Entry plan lacks VIP tiers and dedicated loyalty page
- Pricing:
- Plans start at $199 per month for Entry, $199 for Growth, $499 for Plus, and $999 for Unlimited, with overage charges per additional 100 orders.
- Switching from LoyaltyLion:
- Migration is supported via CSV export/import, and Growave offers a contract buyout to cover your remaining LoyaltyLion commitment.
- RNot published
5.Rise.ai
Best for: Shopify stores that want to automate gift cards, store credit refunds, and cashback to boost retention.

- Pricing
- Not published
- Category
- Other
Rise.ai is a gift card and store credit platform for Shopify stores. It helps you automate refunds, cashback, and loyalty programs to increase repeat purchases. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your main focus is gift cards and store credit rather than a full loyalty program.
Where it is strong
- Handles gift cards, store credit, and cashback in one place
- Includes loyalty programs, referrals, and memberships
- Used by 5000+ brands, with a free trial available
Where it falls short
- No published pricing, so you must contact sales
- Focused on Shopify, so less flexible for other platforms
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site.
- LFrom $50/mo + $50 setu
6.LoyaltyLoop
Best for: Franchises and multi-location businesses that want a managed NPS and review collection process without adding internal workload

- Pricing
- From $50/mo + $50 setu
- Category
- Other
LoyaltyLoop is a fully managed customer feedback platform that sends branded NPS and satisfaction surveys, requests third-party reviews, and alerts you to unhappy customers. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if you want a team to run your feedback and review program for you, rather than a self-serve loyalty points engine.
Where it is strong
- Fully managed setup and ongoing survey management by LoyaltyLoop's team
- Real-time alerts when a customer is unhappy, so you can respond before a public review
- Automatically prompts happy customers to leave Google reviews and captures testimonials
Where it falls short
- No points, tiers, or referral rewards like LoyaltyLion offers
- Pricing is per location, so costs scale quickly for many sites
- Pricing:
- Pilot starts at $50/mo per location plus a $50 one-time setup fee. Annual billing drops it to $45/mo. Promoter and Premier plans are custom-priced.
$249/mo + 1%/order7.Awtomic
Best for: Wineries and ecommerce brands on Shopify that need wine clubs, subscriptions, and memberships with built-in billing and member management.

- Pricing
- $249/mo + 1%/order
- Category
- E-commerce
Awtomic is a Shopify-only platform for wine clubs, subscriptions, and memberships. It handles recurring billing, member portals, and tasting-room POS. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your core business is subscriptions or wine clubs, not just points and rewards.
Where it is strong
- Built for wine clubs and subscriptions with allocations, build-a-box, and shuffles.
- Includes Shopify POS extensions for member signup and card on file at the counter.
- White-glove migration handles stored payment methods, so members don't re-enter cards.
Where it falls short
- Exclusively for Shopify and Shopify Plus, so not usable on other platforms.
- No standalone loyalty points engine like LoyaltyLion's. Rewards are tied to subscription moments.
- Pricing:
- Professional plan is $249/mo + 1% per order, billed monthly with a one-year minimum. Enterprise tier is custom.
- Switching from LoyaltyLion:
- Moving from LoyaltyLion means shifting from a general loyalty program to Awtomic's subscription-focused features, and Awtomic handles migration of members and cards.
Not published8.Appstle Subscriptions
Best for: Shopify merchants who need deep subscription customization and want loyalty, memberships, and bundles in one app.

- Pricing
- Not published
- Category
- E-commerce
Appstle Subscriptions is a Shopify-native app that bundles subscriptions, memberships, loyalty, bundles, and pickup/delivery into one retention toolkit. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your main focus is subscription management and you want loyalty as a secondary feature, not a standalone program.
Where it is strong
- Highly customizable subscription options, including build-a-box and tiered discounts.
- 24/7 support with fast response times, praised in reviews.
- Native Shopify integration with no technical expertise needed for setup.
Where it falls short
- Loyalty features are less mature than LoyaltyLion's AI-driven recommendations.
- Pricing is not transparent, so you need to contact sales for a quote.
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site.
Not published9.Bold Upsell
Best for: Shopify merchants who want to boost AOV with AI-driven upsells and integrate with subscriptions, memberships, and custom pricing tools.

- Pricing
- Not published
- Category
- E-commerce
Bold Upsell is an AI-powered upsell and cross-sell tool for Shopify stores, focused on increasing average order value. It is part of a suite of six apps that work together to drive repeat purchases, subscriptions, and memberships. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your primary goal is maximizing revenue per order and building a repeat-commerce stack, rather than running a traditional points-based loyalty program.
Where it is strong
- AI-powered upsells across cart, checkout, product pages, and post-purchase
- Native Shopify Flow integration for automations without code
- Part of a suite of six apps that share data to drive repeat purchases
Where it falls short
- No loyalty points or rewards features like LoyaltyLion offers
- Pricing not published, so you need to contact sales for a quote
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site.
- Not published
10.Loop Subscriptions
Best for: Shopify brands that sell subscriptions and want to reduce churn with built-in retention tools.

- Pricing
- Not published
- Category
- E-commerce
Loop Subscriptions is a Shopify subscription platform that handles recurring billing, customer portals, failed payment recovery, and cancellation flows. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your main need is managing subscriptions and reducing churn, not running a points-based loyalty program.
Where it is strong
- Flat monthly plans with $0 per-order fees
- Free migration from other subscription apps
- Includes cancellation flow A/B testing and smart dunning
Where it falls short
- No loyalty points or referral features like LoyaltyLion
- Pricing details are not shown on the site
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site.
Not published11.Recharge
Best for: Shopify brands that sell subscriptions and want loyalty features bundled with their subscription management.

- Pricing
- Not published
- Category
- E-commerce
Recharge is a subscription platform for Shopify stores, not a loyalty tool. It handles recurring billing, subscriber management, and churn prevention. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your main need is running a subscription business and you want loyalty features as a secondary add-on.
Where it is strong
- Built for Shopify subscriptions, powering 71% of subscriptions sold on Shopify
- Includes loyalty features like rewards, referrals, and engagement tools
- Hands-on partnership and support team to manage and scale your program
Where it falls short
- Loyalty features are secondary to subscription management, not as deep as LoyaltyLion's
- Pricing is not transparent, requires contacting sales
- Pricing:
- Pricing is not published on the site.
Free / $19 / $99 per m12.Recurpay
Best for: Shopify brands that want a fast-to-launch subscription engine with dunning and a self-serve customer portal

- Pricing
- Free / $19 / $99 per m
- Category
- E-commerce
Recurpay is a Shopify subscription app that helps you turn one-time buyers into subscribers. Choose it over LoyaltyLion if your main goal is managing subscriptions and recovering failed payments, not running a points-based loyalty program.
Where it is strong
- Self-serve customer portal reduces support tickets
- Smart dunning recovers failed subscription payments
- AI-generated widget styling matches your brand without coding
Where it falls short
- No loyalty points, tiers, or referral features like LoyaltyLion
- Only works on Shopify, while LoyaltyLion supports other platforms
- Pricing:
- Launch plan is free with 0% transaction fee. Grow is $19/month. Scale is $99/month.
- Switching from LoyaltyLion:
- Moving from LoyaltyLion means replacing your loyalty program with a subscription focus. You'll need to rebuild any points-based rewards in another tool.
See more comparisons in E-commerce alternatives.
FAQ
Questions about LoyaltyLion alternatives
What is the cheapest LoyaltyLion alternative?
Smile.io offers a free plan for up to 200 monthly orders, then $15 per month for 500 orders. Recurpay has a free Launch plan with 0% transaction fees. Both are cheaper than LoyaltyLion's $199 per month starting price.
Which alternative works on platforms other than Shopify?
Smile.io supports Shopify and BigCommerce. LoyaltyLion itself supports multiple platforms, but most alternatives like Awtomic, Bold Upsell, Recharge, Appstle, Loop, Recurpay, Growave, and Rise.ai are Shopify-only. Yotpo and Klaviyo are platform-agnostic with broad integrations.
Which alternative has the most transparent pricing?
Smile.io publishes full pricing tiers from free to $999 per month. Recurpay lists plans at $0, $19, and $99 per month. LoyaltyLoop shows a $50 per month pilot price. Most others, including Bold Upsell, Yotpo, Recharge, Appstle, Loop, and Rise.ai, require contacting sales.
Can I migrate my existing loyalty program to any of these alternatives?
Smile.io has a dedicated migration team that can carry over members, point balances, and VIP tiers from LoyaltyLion. Awtomic offers white-glove migration for stored payment methods. Growave offers a contract buyout, free until your current loyalty contract ends. Others do not mention migration support.
Which alternative is best for combining loyalty with reviews?
Yotpo combines loyalty, reviews, and AI visibility in one platform. Growave bundles loyalty, referrals, reviews, wishlists, and UGC. LoyaltyLoop focuses on NPS and review collection but lacks points or tiers. Choose Yotpo for AI search control, Growave for a single app, or LoyaltyLoop for managed feedback.
Last updated November 2, 2026.
